• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Legends Eatery

Welcome to Legends Eatery, a charming Italian culinary gem nestled in Pittsburgh's North Side. This family-owned establishment prides itself on crafting exquisite, handmade pasta and delightful dishes that evoke a true taste of Italy. With a cozy ambiance and a BYOB policy, dining here feels intimate and welcoming. Guests rave about the fresh gnocchi, rich bolognese, and mouthwatering seafood options. Legends Eatery not only caters to diverse palates with its pescatarian options but also promotes sustainability with compostable packaging and reusable tableware. Whether you're enjoying dinner with family or having a casual date night, Legends Eatery delivers an unforgettable dining experience.

Legends Eatery: Reviews & Ratings

Craig S.
Craig S.

Great food. BYOB. And I have to type more so I'm doing that Vic numb. Long joining going Huch

Lindsay M.
Lindsay M.

We had a wonderful dinner at Legends on a supposed to be eventful night. We had reservations for a Wednesday before a concert, but the concert was canceled. We decided to keep our reservations, and I am so glad we did! We had arancini and a pizza for an appetizer. The bread along with the arancini was so tasty! The pizza was good not great...try something else at this amazing establishment. My husband and I shared two dinners. We shared the penne vodka and the shrimp pasta...both were delicious! We can not wait to go back and try something other dishes

Carolyn K.
Carolyn K.

Legends is always a great choice! It's BYOB with a cozy atmosphere, delicious food, and great service. We went on a Wednesday night and had one of the best gnocchi dishes I've had in a long time--they make them by hand! The bolognese sauce was perfect, and we started with a tasty pastini soup (daily special). Ideal spot for a date night! Only thing I'd note is that they gave us water cups for the wine instead of wine glasses, which threw me off a bit (I'm particular about my stemware!).

Olivia O.
Olivia O.

One of the best Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh! They have a great selection of food. They are also BYOB

Halie G.
Halie G.

Family owned delicious Italian foods & dessert restaurant located in the North Side. This restaurant is BYOB, highly recommend reservation if you're going on the weekend- they have a very small bar area that's open seating. The most fresh and incredible pasta! Their coconut cream pie is to die for!!!

Ulyana K.
Ulyana K.

I have been wanting to try Legend's for a long time, several years now. And, I finally did it. I tried a pretty solid range of items: the penne vodka, apple pie, house made focaccia bread, and side salad. Let's start with the main course, the penne vodka. I've actually never had this dish before, but I thought it was very well made! The portion was definitely adequate, and it was clearly high quality. It's quite creamy, and doesn't taste like vodka at all. A tad bit of sweetness to it too. There's not much prosciutto, and it was all just kind of one clump in the bottom of the pasta, but it was still good. The side salad served complimentary with it was actually surprisingly good. Not just lettuce and cucumbers like in many other places. They had carrots, onions, spinach, blue cheese, and a very tasty ranch. The ranch, while very good, had a sort of grainy-ness to it, in texture. Other than that, fresh and very good! The little pieces of bread were also a lovely complimentary treat. I believe they are made in house, and I loved them. They'd be even better with a little oil (and I think they do have that option as an appetizer). Finally, the caramel apple pie. It was good, but a bit of a let down. The crust was kind of flavorless, and there wasn't really a strong caramel flavor to it. It was still good, and a great serving (although also pretty expensive), but not the best I've had. All in all, a very good, quantity, little Italian spot on the North side. Great spot for celebrations and high quality food. I would recommend!

Tiffany Y.
Tiffany Y.

Legends Eatery opened in 2002 and serves old-school Italian-American cuisine in a casual atmosphere. Its menu lists appetizers such as mussels and meatballs, entrees such as veal parmigiano and fettuccini alfredo, and desserts such as fried cannolis and chocolate cake. The restaurant serves beverages such as sodas, coffees, and teas but is BYOB for alcohol. The restaurant's website recommends making a weekend reservation at least two weeks in advance, so I instead ordered food through their website for pickup. After 24 minutes, the restaurant emailed me that my food was ready. The restaurant is located near Allegheny General Hospital and appears to have limited parking, so my husband dropped me off and drove around the neighborhood while I went inside the restaurant to pick up the food. An employee immediately and kindly greeted me, handed over my bag of food, asked if I needed any utensils, and thanked me. Here are my reviews for my foods: Penne blackened shrimp ~ $21 - 4.5 stars - The penne pasta was cooked well, and it was topped with delicious shrimp, cherry tomatoes, portobello mushrooms, oil, and garlic. On the side were a small salad with my choice of balsamic dressing and an add-on of a few small slices of focaccia bread. Caesar salad ~ $18 - 3.5 stars - The mixed greens, olives, red peppers, and cheese were very fresh. I had not ordered chicken, but the restaurant included chicken. Caesar dressing was in separate containers. Meatball parm sandwich ~ $17 - 3 stars - My husband ordered this hoagie, and he ate only half of it. The hoagie roll was from Breadworks, and it contained large meatballs, cheese, and sauce. On the side was a small salad with mixed greens, carrots, onions, cucumbers, cheese, and my husband's choice of ranch dressing. Mozzarella ~ $10 - 3 stars - Large triangular chunks of mozzarella cheese were fried, and my husband ate most of them. On the side was marinara sauce. I also had ordered a 6.75-ounce bottle of Perrier for ~ $6, but I did not have a bottle opener to open it, so I saved it for later.

Location

  • Legends Eatery
    500 E North Ave Pittsburgh, PA 15212 United States Hotline: (412) 321-8000

Welcome to Legends Eatery, a charming gem nestled in the heart of Pittsburgh’s North Side. This delightful Italian restaurant offers a culinary journey rich in tradition and flavor, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors alike.

Legends Eatery strikes a perfect balance between a casual atmosphere and superb dining, featuring everything from homemade gnocchi to mouthwatering seafood pasta dishes. The cozy ambiance invites you to relax and savor each bite, making it an ideal spot for anything from a romantic date night to a lively family dinner.

  • Highlights:
  • Handmade pasta that sets them apart, providing a taste of Italy right in Pittsburgh.
  • BYOB policy, allowing guests to pair their favorite wines with delicious dishes.
  • A range of options catering to dietary preferences, including pescatarian choices.
  • Modern conveniences such as QR code menus, outdoor seating, and heated areas for year-round dining.

As you step inside, you’ll notice the friendly staff ready to serve you with smiles. Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends, due to the restaurant’s growing popularity. Guests have noted the excellent service and the attention to detail, ensuring your dining experience is unforgettable.

Customer reviews highlight the deliciousness of several dishes, from the perfectly cooked penne vodka and scrumptious shrimp pasta to the standout arancini and the freshly baked bread that complements your meal beautifully. Don’t miss the delightful coconut cream pie that patrons rave about—it’s a sweet ending worth saving room for!

Conveniently located at 500 E North Ave, Legends Eatery is more than just a place to eat; it’s a community hub bringing people together around great food and quality hospitality. With accessible parking and options for delivery, takeout, and catering, they make it easy to enjoy their offerings however you prefer.

Next time you’re in the mood for authentic Italian fare, look no further than Legends Eatery. You’ll leave with a full belly and a heart warmed by the essence of their culinary endeavors.